The Best Pizza in the Triangle, By Style: NY Slice, Neapolitan, Detroit, and Wood-Fired
Because “best pizza” is the wrong question — the right question is what are you hungry for right now.
There are people in this region who will argue about pizza the way other people argue about barbecue. Which is to say: loudly, personally, and without much interest in being wrong. That’s fine. Pizza arguments are productive arguments. But most pizza debates collapse because they’re comparing incompatible things — like judging a baguette against a croissant and declaring one of them bread.
A great New York slice and a great Neapolitan pie are not the same food. They have different textures, different hydration levels, different crust structures, different ideal eating temperatures. One you fold in half on a paper plate. The other you eat with a fork in a candlelit room. A Detroit pan pizza is closer to focaccia than either of them. Wood-fired is its own church entirely.
So instead of telling you where to find the “best pizza” in the Triangle — a sentence that means nothing — here’s where to find the best version of each style. When you know what you’re craving, you’ll know where to go.
NY Slice: Pizzeria Mercato — Cary
1540 NW Maynard Rd, Cary, NC 27513
If you grew up in New York or New Jersey, or if you’ve spent any time at a fold-and-go counter in a city that takes this stuff seriously, Pizzeria Mercato is going to scratch that itch. This is a full-service restaurant, but the real business is the slice window — wide 18-inch pies sold by the slice, with that particular floppy-but-structural quality that separates New York pizza from everything pretending to be New York pizza.
The crust has real chew to it, with enough char on the bottom to hold up under a full load of toppings. The sauce is bright and acidic without being sweet. The mozzarella pulls without turning into a rubber sheet. Get a plain slice first. That’s the test. If the plain slice holds up — if the ratio of sauce to cheese to crust is in balance without any distraction — then you’re in the right place. It does. [VERIFY current hours and slice availability at the window]
Parking is easy in the shopping center lot. The slice counter tends to move fast at lunch. Cash-friendly but cards accepted.
NY Slice: Lilly’s Pizza — Raleigh
1813 Lynn Rd, Raleigh, NC 27612
Lilly’s has been in Five Points since 1993, which in Raleigh restaurant years is basically a geological epoch. The atmosphere is cluttered and loud in the best way — covered in local art, mismatched furniture, and the kind of energy that says nobody here is trying to make this a vibe. It already has one.
The pizza is New York-influenced but tilts toward creative. The crust is thin and foldable, the selection of specialty pies is genuinely interesting without being gimmicky. The Thai peanut chicken pizza sounds wrong and is right. The standard margherita is reliable. The sauce is tangy with real garlic presence. This is not the spot for a minimalist plain slice experience — it’s the spot when you want something with personality and a beer on the side.
Seating fills up fast on weekend nights. Go early or expect to wait. Delivery and takeout are popular in the neighborhood. Street parking on Lynn and in the small lot adjacent.
Neapolitan: Pizzeria Faulisi — Durham
1125 N Mangum St, Durham, NC 27701
Neapolitan pizza has rules. The Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, a real organization out of Naples, certifies pizzerias that follow the traditional standards: specific flour, San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte or buffalo mozzarella, 90-second bake in a wood-burning oven at around 900 degrees Fahrenheit, soft and slightly charred crust with a puffy cornicione. Pizzeria Faulisi takes all of that seriously.
The pies here are personal-sized, with that characteristic soupy center — the wet middle that some people mistake for undercooking but is actually a feature, not a bug. It means the toppings are fresh and the moisture hasn’t been cooked out of everything. The margherita is the baseline and it’s excellent. The burrata they serve alongside some pies is worth ordering on its own. The room is warm and small, the wine list is short and well-chosen.
This is not a casual pizza-on-the-couch situation. Come for dinner, take your time, and eat it fresh. Neapolitan pizza does not travel well. The crust goes soft within minutes. Eat here, not in your car. [VERIFY current hours and reservation policy]
Neapolitan: Pizzeria Toro — Durham
105 W Main St, Durham, NC 27701
Pizzeria Toro earns its reputation on consistency and craft. It’s been a downtown Durham anchor [VERIFY years of operation] with a wood-burning oven at the center of the room that you can watch through the open kitchen. The crust is blistered and soft with that slight sour note that comes from a long fermentation. The San Marzano tomato sauce is clean and uncluttered.
Order the Toro — their house pie — but don’t skip the starter situation. The whipped ricotta with honey, or whatever vegetable preparation they’re running with the season, tends to be as good as the pizza itself. The bar program is real. This is a full dinner out, not just a pizza stop. Reservations recommended on weekends. Walk-ins are possible at the bar, which is often the better seat anyway.
Street parking downtown or the decks nearby. Budget for a full meal, not just a pie.
Detroit-Style: Glasstown Pizza — Durham
[VERIFY current address — Glasstown has operated in Durham’s food hall and pop-up spaces]
Detroit-style pizza is having a national moment, and for good reason: it’s excellent. Baked in a square blue steel pan, it develops a lacy, caramelized cheese crust along all four edges — that’s called frico, and it’s the whole point. The dough is thick and airy, almost focaccia-like in its interior texture, with a crisp bottom from the well-oiled pan. The sauce goes on top of the cheese, not under it. It’s backwards from what you’re used to, and it’s better.
Glasstown does this style well — serious attention to the pan technique, the right cheese blend for edge caramelization, and sauce that doesn’t get lost under the weight of toppings. The pepperoni cups (the small, thick-cut rounds that curl and crisp in the oven) are the correct topping choice. This is a heavy, satisfying pizza. One or two squares and a drink is a full meal. [VERIFY current location, availability, and hours — Glasstown’s format has evolved]
Detroit-Style: Boxcar Bar + Arcade — Raleigh
427 W Martin St, Raleigh, NC 27601
Yes, this is primarily an arcade bar. Yes, the pizza is worth talking about. Boxcar has served Detroit-style pies from their downtown Raleigh location [VERIFY current menu — pizza offering may have changed], and when they’re on, they’re on. The thick, pillowy squares with that essential cheese-fry edge hold up under the loud, dim, quarters-in-machines environment that Boxcar operates in.
This is not a destination pizza meal. This is the pizza you eat while losing at Pac-Man, which is its own category of satisfying. If the pizza has cycled off the menu or changed format, treat this entry as due diligence — call ahead. But if it’s there, it’s worth ordering alongside whatever craft beer they’ve got on tap.
Parking in the lot or street. Gets loud and crowded Thursday through Saturday nights. Earlier in the evening for a more relaxed experience.
Wood-Fired: Caffe Luna — Raleigh
136 S Wilmington St, Raleigh, NC 27601
Caffe Luna is one of those restaurants that has been in downtown Raleigh long enough that people take it for granted, which is a mistake. The wood-fired oven at the back of this Italian restaurant produces pizzas with a particular flavor that a deck oven or conveyor simply cannot replicate — there’s a slight smokiness in the char, a depth to the crust that comes from live fire and cast-iron floor temperatures.
The pizza is Roman in spirit — thin, crisp, not soupy in the center, well-distributed toppings. The prosciutto and arugula pie is the one to get. Order it and let the arugula wilt slightly on top of the hot crust. The lunch service here is underrated — faster, less expensive, and you’ll usually get a table without waiting. The dinner room has old-school romantic-Italian energy that’s genuinely pleasant. [VERIFY current hours and menu availability]
Parking downtown — use the nearby decks on Wilmington or Davie. Reservations smart for weekend dinner.
Wood-Fired: Oakleaf — Durham
608 N Mangum St, Durham, NC 27701
Oakleaf operates as a neighborhood restaurant with the kind of calm confidence that doesn’t need to announce itself. The wood-fired oven anchors the kitchen and it shows up in everything — not just the pizza, but the way vegetables char and the way proteins finish. The pizza here is thin-crust and personal, with toppings that rotate seasonally and lean local.
This is the pizza for people who care where the mushrooms came from. The sourcing is real, not decorative. The crust has character — chewy at the cornicione, crisp toward the middle, with the distinctive wood-fire flavor underneath everything. The natural wine list is one of the better ones in Durham for a neighborhood spot. Come for a quiet weeknight dinner. [VERIFY current hours, menu format, and reservation policy]
A Few Rules for Eating Pizza in the Triangle
Don’t order Neapolitan to go. It’s not that they won’t let you. It’s that you’re wasting your money. Neapolitan pizza has a lifespan of about ten minutes before the crust softens into something completely different. Eat it in the restaurant or don’t bother.
The plain slice tells you everything. Before you load up on toppings at any new spot, order a margherita or a plain cheese first. You’ll learn more about the dough, the sauce, and the cheese quality from that single slice than from anything buried under roasted vegetables and specialty cured meats.
Detroit pizza reheats. Unlike most pizza, the thick pan style actually comes back well in a cast iron skillet with a lid. Crisp the bottom on medium heat, steam the top. Better than you think.
Pizza by the slice has almost disappeared from the Triangle. This is a real problem. Most of the places above are full-pie operations. If you want a casual, drop-in slice experience, your options are genuinely limited. This is an opening in the market, if anyone’s paying attention.
Don’t rank styles against each other. A great Detroit pan square is not worse than a great Neapolitan pie because it’s thicker. A great NY slice is not inferior because it came out of a deck oven instead of a wood-fired one. Different tools. Different results. Both worth eating.
The Triangle pizza scene is better than it was five years ago and still growing. There are operators here who care deeply about fermentation, flour sourcing, and fire management. That’s the right foundation. The rest follows.
The Path Best Traveled is a local insider’s guide to the Triangle. New stories weekly.